Process Solutions

Future-proofing Potash Mining: The Need for Intelligent Operations Ten billion tons of potash reserves. Put another way, reserves that exceed global annual production by more than 300 times. And...

Resource Center Whitepapers, Videos, Case Studies

Mining Markets

Palladium Overtakes PlatinumWith the exception of lead and zinc, which posted month-on-month gains of $146 per metric ton (mt) and $77.50/mt, respectively, most metals gave up some of the August...
More inMarkets  

Mining Operations & Strategies

Calculating Mine-site Volumes From Space Satellite imaging provides a safe, fast and cost-effective alternative to ground-based open-pit mining surveys In today’s competitive commodities...

Suppliers Report

Belzona Repairs Barrick Slurry Tank Belzona repaired a slurry tank damaged by corrosion at Barrick Gold Corp.’s Dominican Republic mine, Pueblo Viejo. The tank was used to neutralize acidic sludge to a...
More inSuppliers Report  

Mining Equipment Gallery

New Rotary Blasthole Drill Caterpillar announced its new MD6310 rotary blasthole drill enables efficiency and productivity improvements. Cat electronics deliver advanced troubleshooting for...

Afghan Metal: Sustainable Trade for a Stable Future


Dear Editor:
If history tells us anything, it is that lopsided deals create disastrous long term results. History seems to have a ready template. The weaker country usually lacks a proper overseer, executor, trustee or fiduciary that has the strength to negotiate a mutually beneficial deal. The foreign company grows frustrated with the weaker country’s tactics and inability to satisfy its needs, so it asks its home country to influence the weaker country into making a deal. The parties then strike a deal, with terms clearly advantageous to the foreign company. Not long thereafter, a nationalist revolt by the native population ensues.

In the end, foreign companies and the native populaces have paid consistently and dearly for such upheavals that are born from unrealistically asymmetrical trade deals.

Afghanistan’s future plight may be no different than the historical norm. Afghanistan’s newly (re)discovered natural resources place it in the sights of many a foreign power. Both India and China, in addition to Western economic forces, will welcome going to their own backyard rather than going to far-flung locations such as Sierre Leone and Angola, respectively, for the extraction of important raw materials. So how will Afghanistan prepare to negotiate for positive terms that are both economically and politically sustainable for itself and simultaneously attractive for multinational investment? Much of its educated and financially-capable elite that would have been groomed for the task have long since fled and have yet to return as the fighting and instability continues.

The resources beneath the earth cannot readily be taken and used to supply the war chests of bandit-armies in the way cocaine does for the FARC in Colombia, heroin does for the Taliban, or blood diamonds have done for certain militia groups in sub-Saharan Africa. It is not, as some argue, within the scope of the Taliban's core competency to gain control over the scattered locations of the discovered veins of valuable metals. After all, they carry Kalashnikovs, not hard hats and blueprints, and if they had the expertise to develop the mines, they would have done so based on the old plans the Russians had already developed. That line of reasoning resembles exploring why the Maoist rebels in India have not developed a tech support call center for Dell computers.

Valuable metals, like oil, require order, peace, and technology to be profitably and consistently extracted, as the hiatus in infrastructural development created by decades of continuous war has shown it to be true in Afghanistan.  It is imperative for a new approach: the borrowing of competent, experienced experts and power players to act as fiduciaries to oversee the development of Afghanistan’s mining industry in this time of transition.

This “Council of Fiduciaries” must be made up of an alliance of both the most important stakeholders of Afghanistan’s future as well as international experts in order to imbue any trade deal with the oversight and enforcement needed to create sustainable long term business endeavors to develop a mining industry. With strong and wise fiduciaries overseeing Afghanistan as its trustees, whether they come from a powerful domestic elite, the U.S. Government, NGOs, international entities, a consortium of private companies or some competent mixture of the players mentioned, Afghanistan may stand a fighting chance and avoid monopolistic control over its resources, and reciprocally, international firms can see a more stable environment for their operations to continue for the long term. Consequently, Afghanistan, international firms and countries associated with the latter, may all prosper. More regulated competition among the seekers of this resource also means a stronger natural negotiating stance for the people of Afghanistan and their government and more checks on abuses both from outside the government and within it.  

New stable and self-sustaining industries can one day incorporate former insurgents into mainstream industry and rehabilitate a large part the country's potential manpower away from warfare and drug trafficking, spreading peace and development rather than destruction. The profits Afghanistan will recover from mining can surely boost its investment in infrastructure, creating opportunities for valuable reinvestment in the development of the nation. Much needed roads, schools, agricultural programs, and a myriad of other infrastructural programs, will all spring up with proper management and oversight. Through benevolent stewardship and oversight of negotiation and reinvestment by the U.S. and its fellow trustees, Afghanistan can heal, grow and re-enter the world market.

Responsible and well-regulated globalization can help Afghanistan avoid the instabilities that have plagued many other nations while setting the stage for its advancement. However, until global fiduciaries come together to shield Afghanistan from the world's raw hunger for its metals, Afghanistan, despite years of unfathomable endurance, remains an exposed and vulnerable nation unprepared to face its greatest challenge and source of progress yet: international trade.  

Sincerely,

Dean Dastvar
J.D. Candidate, Washington College of Law (2011)
E-mail: [email protected]

From the Editor

A Trustworthy Voice As this edition of Engineering & Mining Journal (E&MJ) was going to press, the top lawyers from Google, Facebook and Twitter had testified before a U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee. They were trying to explain how internet trolls had used their social media platforms to spread misinformation in the months leading up to the...
More inFrom The Editor  

Exploration Roundup

Osisko Drilling 400,000 m at Windfall Lake Osisko Mining has reported numerous favorable results from an ongoing, 400,000-meter (m) drill program at its Windfall Lake gold project in Urban Township,...

This Month in Coal Mining

Whitehaven Posts Impressive Results Whitehaven Coal, Australia’s leading independent coal company with five operating mines in northwest New South Wales, has reported a net profit after tax of...